Tuesday, October 20, 2015

Why every lead pastor must consider a strategic, intentional succession plan

This past week I spent just over an hour speaking with a pastor in his 60s at a church in another city. My new friend has been senior pastor at his church for over 30 years. He feels it is time for him to develop a plan of succession. He had heard from one of our members here at Cuyahoga Valley Church that we have transitioned leadership, at least according to our member's perspective, in a way that has preserved the best of the past and forged a brighter future.

The pastor wanted to talk with me about succession. He had prepared a list of questions for us to discuss. I hope the conversation was beneficial for him.

As I have reflected on the conversation, I have begun to think a little more about the "why" of succession.

I have often said, "There is no success without a successor." I think that this statement is true as long as "success "is well defined.

What is "success" for church? To be sure, Cuyahoga Valley has experienced what the world might call success in terms of the ABCs: Attendance, Buildings, and Cash. But just because a church knows it's ABC's does not mean that it is successful in the sight of God.

Success to God may not look like success in the eyes of the world. Success to God may look simple, but it is profound: Loving God. Loving one another. Glorify God. Making disciples. Being a pillar of truth. Guarding sound doctrine. Pursuing justice. Walking humbly. Seeking first the kingdom. Living new. Creating a caring community. Linking generations.

We could go on and on. But you get the idea. You can add your own successes in God's eyes to this list. These are the things that we know instinctively make for true success in the eyes of God.

Passing the leadership torch so that a church is successful in the ABC's - that attendance stays strong, the building is current, and the cash keeps flowing - is not why a leader should consider how to best transition.

No. A church leader is a pastor. And at the heart of being a pastor is being a shepherd.

I'm opposed to the too-often practiced strategy of those pastors who turn in a two week notice and then leave the sheep without proper care. It might sound harsh, but I think that this kind of so-called leader does not have the spirit of a pastor but has the spirit of a mercenary. A shepherd does not take care of the sheep only when he is employed as a shepherd and gets a pay check.

A shepherd takes care of the sheep. Period. He feeds, waters, and protects his flock. He's concerned about the sheep even when he's not around or no longer in the lead shepherd role. So, when it is time for a shepherd to leave senior leadership responsibilities for his flock, he does so, if he truly loves the individual sheep, while carefully and prayerfully empowering and equipping a successor-shepherd.

In this sense, then, a succession plan that is successful in the eyes of God is rooted and grounded in love for God's sheep and a desire to preserve the health of the flock of God.

A true pastor wants the church to continue to be successful in the eyes of God: Following Christ. Depending on God. Abiding in Christ. Being filled with the Spirit. Bearing the fruit of the Spirit. Creating a just society. Setting captives free. Rebuilding ancient ruins. Restoring brokenness. Rejoicing in all things.

I urge pastors everywhere to follow your most noble and most loving instincts to care for the flock that you have said that you love and that God has given you. Continue to love them well even after you have passed the torch of leadership. And one very significant way to do that this to be thoughtful, prayerful, and strategic as to how you passed the torch of leadership to the next generation.

If you would like to discuss lead pastor transition issues, then email me a rick@auxano.com. I'd love to share what we've learned over the past 5 years at CVC. 

No comments:

Post a Comment